How Should Your Investment Strategy
Change as You Approach Retirement?
Working with clients as financial advisors, we have heard all sorts of stories where retirement goes awry. For example, during the financial crisis in 2008, we’ve been told of multiple instances in which an individual intended to retire but, due to market volatility, continued working longer than intended. Another common story: individuals who retired with a steady pension that did not adjust for inflation. After many years of sustained inflation, they were forced back into the workforce, or experienced a reduced standard of living. In today’s post, we’ll talk about how we balance the risks of market volatility and inflation in the investment strategy of pre-retirees and retirees as part of our retirement planning process.
Stairsteps Up. Elevator Down.
“Stairsteps up, elevator down” is a phrase used in the financial industry to describe the idea that stock prices tend to climb slowly over time, but when a crisis hits, they can lose value quickly. This matters more at age 60 than at 35. A 35-year-old won’t need to live off their retirement savings anytime soon and has many years to recover. A 60-year-old, by contrast, will need to use their retirement savings sooner rather than later. A significant loss during a crisis could reduce the amount of retirement income they can generate in the future.
For example, from 2000–2002, the S&P 500 lost roughly 49% of its value. For investors to get back to even, the market had to increase by approximately 96%, a process that took roughly 7 years from the market’s prior peak. From 2007–2009, the market lost roughly 57% of its value. In this instance, the market needed to rise approximately 131%, a process that took roughly 5.5 years from the prior peak.* In either of these instances, a 60-year-old who was over-allocated to stocks may have found their retirement delayed, or their retirement income diminished.
Compounding this issue, if a retiree is taking withdrawals from their account and is over-allocated to stocks, this may force them to sell stocks at low prices, locking in losses and missing the stock market recovery. This is known as sequence-of-returns risk: losses early in retirement can hurt more than losses later on, because the retiree is selling to fund withdrawals.
The Silent Risk: Inflation
More often than not, we run into portfolios that are taking too much risk. But taking too little risk can be just as damaging to retirement savings. With 401(k)s, 403(b)s, and IRAs, there is no built-in inflation adjustment for the value of the typical retirement account. Even in periods of normal inflation, the real, or inflation-adjusted, value of the portfolio could decline over time, limiting the investor’s ability to draw income from their savings.
For instance, a $1,000,000 portfolio invested in non-interest-bearing cash over 30 years would be worth $412,000 in inflation-adjusted terms, assuming 3% annual inflation. Retirements can easily last for 25–30 years or more, so this is not a theoretical exercise. The question is, how do we balance the need for growth assets to keep up with inflation against the stock market risk we discussed in the previous section?
Building a Pre-Retirement Portfolio
You need to find a way to keep growth assets, like stocks, in your portfolio, while at the same time not subjecting yourself to unneeded volatility that would put your retirement income in jeopardy. While we can’t go into full detail in the space provided, we can give some general guidelines.
5–10 years before retirement, it generally makes sense to take a more conservative approach to retirement investing. This means investing in less volatile assets. Your risk tolerance, spending patterns, amount of income covered by Social Security or a pension, and when you’ll begin withdrawing all play a role in formulating this asset allocation. Someone with a steady income stream from outside their portfolio (like a pension) may be able to afford more risk than someone who relies solely on their portfolio for income.
Many investors think of bonds as being less risky. While this is true of certain types of bonds, if you invest in high-yield bonds, you’ll find they perform more like stocks. And long-duration bonds, like 30-year Treasuries, are vulnerable to rising interest rates and lost over 50% of their value from 2020 to 2023.** Shorter-duration government bonds are less susceptible to both interest rate and credit risk. Note that if you don’t have sufficient time or experience to dedicate to investing, you may want assistance in building this “pre-retirement” portfolio. In the next section, we’ll discuss the way we help clients navigate volatility and inflation when constructing retirement portfolios.
Our Dynamic Approach
Market conditions are never static. You can expect to experience many types of markets over the course of your investing lifetime.
Ever-changing markets call for a dynamic approach to portfolio construction. Dynamic means that the portfolio allocation changes with market conditions. Sometimes growth stocks lead the market, sometimes value stocks. Sometimes international stocks outperform domestic stocks. And sometimes it makes more sense to have a larger bond allocation than a larger stock allocation.
We partner with third-party, independent research groups that use advanced quantitative models to help us gauge economic conditions, recession risk, interest-rate trends, and the parts of the market that look stronger or weaker. The independent research groups we use provide only research, meaning the material they produce is not meant to sell a product but rather to help us make better decisions on behalf of our clients.
During periods of stock headwinds, such as a recession, we would reduce our clients’ stock exposure based on research signals. During periods with rising interest rates, we would shorten our clients’ bond duration. As a client approaches retirement, we take extra care to evaluate their portfolio construction in light of their near-term income needs. These changes don’t eliminate risk altogether, but they do help us manage it in light of client goals. While we trust the data-based processes we follow, no system is ever perfect. But following a disciplined, data-informed process enables us to act thoughtfully and removes an emotional element from our decision-making. Learn more about our investment management services.
Next Steps
Markets are unpredictable. As you get closer to retirement, it is important that volatility or inflation doesn’t throw you off course. If you haven’t taken a close look at your asset allocation in light of your retirement goals, please book a meeting at the link below. We’ll review your current allocation and expected income needs, and run scenario analyses to help you construct a more robust retirement portfolio.
*Source: S&P 500 price index, peak-to-trough declines and recovery to prior peak. Stacker, “Every Major Stock Market Correction Since 1950 and How Long Recovery Took.”
**Based on the price decline of the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (TLT), August 2020 to October 2023.
